Microfinance: Indebting the Poorest in the World
In the previous article, we read about the theoretical concept of microfinance. This theoretical concept has been sold to the major financial organizations of the world that have pumped in billions to expand the reach of microfinance. Microfinance is now a major part of the poor economies right from Bolivia to Bosnia to Bangladesh.
However, the reality of microfinance seems to be the exact opposite. Most of the studies that were full of praises for the concept of microfinance were commissioned by the companies that were pursuing the business of microfinance themselves. Needless to say that these studies had vested interests and wanted to make microfinance look better than it is. Therefore, when unbiased studies were conducted, a lot of issues with microfinance were discovered. It seemed like microfinance was, in fact, indebting the poor and making the companies rich and the whole win-win model was a hoax.
In this article, we will consider the criticisms that have been levelled by some of the biggest critics of microfinance:
Not for Productive Purposes
Studies conducted to investigate the real impact of microfinance found out that most of the loans that were being made were not being used for productive purposes. Therefore, even though the intended purpose of the loans was to start micro enterprises, very few individuals that borrowed the money used it for this purpose. Instead, the money was being used to finance consumption expenses like marriage or medical issues. The microfinance companies had not developed a mechanism to ensure that the money being loaned out was being used for the intended purpose. Over and above that microfinance companies were also giving out a lot of consumer loans. A large portion of the loans being made were actually consumer finance loans aiding the purchase of mobile phones and other electronic gadgets.
The microfinance model, therefore, started to look like the subprime model. People below the poverty line were borrowing money for consumption purposes and did not seem to have any source of income to pay it back! The objective of poverty reduction appeared to be replaced by the debt spiral, that many borrowers found themselves in. They were borrowing more money to keep up with the payments of the old loans.
Usurious Interest Rates
Microfinance was called a significant innovation because it had supposedly created a way for the profit motive as well as the social reason to co-exist. However, this did not seem like the case, when studies revealing the true nature of microfinance activities were published.
The microfinance rates were given out at an average interest rate of 23% per annum! This meant that the microfinance companies were simply taking advantage of the lack of interest rate regulations in the developing nations and loaning out money at extremely high-interest rates. Studies revealed that over 50% of the disposable income of the poor households was being used only to service the interest on the debt. The repayment of principal and closing of the loan was, therefore, a farfetched thought!
Demand for Goods and Services Not Increased
The basis of the microfinance model was that micro enterprises would help to alleviate poverty. However, studies have shown that the whole idea of micro enterprises has ended up being a failure. Micro-enterprises have the potential to increase the supply of goods. However, that does not automatically create new demands for the goods or services being produced. In most economies, the demand is fairly stagnant. Hence, when more production takes places, the demand is simply spread out amongst many more enterprises. It bankrupts quite a few of them as oversupply also causes prices to drop and eats into the profit margins of the small businessmen.
The top management at a lot of these microfinance institutions simply wanted to make the company look bigger and bigger. They had their personal hidden incentives. If they could make the business appear bigger than it was, they could justify the fat pay packages that they were obtaining. Also, they could justify the giving out of employee stock options which they could cash in during the IPO process making millions as a result.
Thus, the management of microfinance companies started pushing credit like never seen before in these markets. Microfinance loans were growing at the rate of 60% per year i.e. they would more than triple every two years! In hindsight most of the new loans were given to the same borrowers i.e. they were loans given to service the previous loans. Therefore, a lot of these loans were likely to end up the nonperforming assets, the moment they were sanctioned. Yet the management gave out these loans, knowing full well, how they were likely to end up.
Many critics allege that the biggest capitalist organizations in the world have been supporting the idea of microfinance for political motives. Microfinance deflects the responsibility from the government. The government is no longer required to provide better education and technology to the poor. Instead, the focus shifts on individual entrepreneurship which is just self-employment in menial tasks. Also, it takes the attention off of labour unions and labour laws allowing the capitalists to conduct their business unobstructed!
Microfinance has therefore proven to be economically unviable. Most of the microfinance institutions that were booming in 2010 are now facing losses. However, only time will tell whether this is the end or whether there is another twist to this microfinance story?
|❮❮ Previous||Next ❯❯|
Authorship/Referencing - About the Author(s)
The article is Written By Prachi Juneja and Reviewed By Management Study Guide Content Team. MSG Content Team comprises experienced Faculty Member, Professionals and Subject Matter Experts. We are a ISO 2001:2015 Certified Education Provider. To Know more, click on About Us. The use of this material is free for learning and education purpose. Please reference authorship of content used, including link(s) to ManagementStudyGuide.com and the content page url.
- Corporate Finance - Introduction
- Nominal and Real Value of Money
- Fundamental Rules of Corporate Finance
- Present and Future Value of Money
- Net Present Value Calculations
- Compounding Intervals and Interest Rate
- What Are Negative Interest Rates ?
- The Consequences of Negative Interest Rates
- Opportunity Cost of Capital
- Valuing Cash Flows in Different Periods
- What is Perpetuity ?
- Growing Perpetuity
- What is Annuity ?
- Ordinary Annuity vs. Annuity Due
- Types of Annuity Calculations
- What is Bond Valuation ?
- Bond Market Conventions
- How Interest Rates Affect Bonds ?
- Stock Valuation Models
- Discounted Cash Flow Approach
- Assumptions During Stock Valuation
- What is Cost of Equity ?
- What is Payback Period ?
- What is Internal Rate of Return (IRR) ?
- Problems With Using IRR
- Capital Rationing & Profitability Index
- Types of Capital Rationing
- Capital Controls: Meaning, Types, Benefits and Downside
- Estimating Project Cash Flows: Part 1
- Estimating Project Cash Flows: Part 2
- Estimating Project Cash Flows: Part 3
- Capital Budgeting and Inflation
- Capital Budgeting and Depreciation
- Equivalent Annual Costs
- Investing and Financing Decisions
- Getting Creative with Capital Budgeting
- The Fallacy of Creative Destruction
- Companys Risk vs. Project Risk
- How Governments around the World are Bankrupting Future Generations for Present Consumption
- Role of Credit Rating Agencies in Determining Attractiveness of Companies and Countries
- Federal Reserve Announcement to Taper Quantitative Easing
- How Do Funds Transfer Systems Work
- The Importance of KYC (Know Your Customer) Norms and Procedures in Banking
- Difference between Corporate, Retail, Investment Banking, and Private Banking
- Impact of Geography on Banking and its Functions
- Functions of a Central Bank in Modern Economies
- Lease Rental Discounting
- Lending Against Intangible Assets
- Real Reasons behind FDI in Retail in India
- Microfinance: A Cure for Poverty
- Microfinance: Indebting the Poorest in the World
- Behind the Scenes of an Initial Public Offer (IPO)
- Pros and Cons of Going Public
- Snapchat IPO: Is this the New Tech Bubble ?
- Benefits of Delaying Profitability
- Why Do Corporations Get Away With Tax Avoidance ?
- After Effects of the Nirav Modi Scam
- The Panaya Acquisition
- The Flipkart and Wal-Mart Alliance
- The Worlds Largest IPO
- Initial Coin Offerings: A Primer
- The Aftermath of the Qualcomm Deal
- What are Demergers: Its Pros and Cons
- Benefits of a Holding Company
- The Economics of Lawsuits
- Protectionist Sentiment over Flipkart Takeover
- The Impact of Tariffs on the Energy Sector
- Venture Debt A Primer
- Interest Rates and Automobile Sales
- How Should Companies Communicate With Wall Street?
- How an Interest Rate Hike Will Affect the Government of USA
- Is Tesla Close to Bankruptcy?
- Myths Surrounding Toys R Us Bankruptcy
- The Economics of 'Soda Taxes'
- Why Elon Musk's Tesla Should Go Private and Why It Won't?
- Why the Xiaomi IPO Failed?
- How A Whatsapp Message Nearly Took Down A Company
- The Case for Index Funds
- The Sears Bankruptcy
- The Socialization of Losses
- The Sudden Downfall of IL&FS
- Why Healthy Corporate-Regulator Tussle is Good for Free Market Capitalist Economies
- What Happens When Businesses Go Bankrupt? Insolvency, Aftermath, and Recovery
- Alibabas Singles Day
- Ubers New Businesses
- Goldman Sachs and the 1MDB Scandal
- The Amazon Divorce
- Are Index Funds Not A Good Investment In India?
- Can Brick And Mortar Stores Compete With Amazon?
- Why is the Fed Still Raising Interest Rates?
- Problems Related to Facebook, WhatsApp, and Instagram Mega Merger
- The Whatsapp-Facebook-Instagram Merger
- What Is The DHFL Scam?
- Financial Troubles In the Fracking Industry
- Flipkart Circumvents Indias FDI Norms
- Subprime Automobile Loans in America
- The Jaguar Land Rover Debacle
- The Kraft - Heinz Fallout
- Why Uber Should Be Regulated?
- Is Regulation of the Tech Sector Long Overdue with the Tech Giants being Too Big
- The Fall of An Ambani Scion
- Litigation Funding: A Primer
- The Finance behind the Plastic Problem
- The MasterCard Visa Duopoly
- Is the Lyft IPO Overpriced?
- The Alliance between Car Companies and Ride Hailing Apps
- The Amazon Divorce Deal
- The Lawsuit Between Spotify and Apple Corporation
- The Story Behind the L&T- Mindtree Takeover Bid
- Do IPOs Affect Competitive Firms?
- Can Cost Cutting Turn Out To Be Expensive?
- The Economic Impact of Facebook Outage
- The Apple-Qualcomm Legal Battle
- Cross Border Credit Reporting
- The Sudden Deluge of Unicorn IPOs
- The Wow Airline Debacle
- The WeWork Business Model
- Problem with Private Securities Offerings
- The Amazon FedEx Breakup
- The Decline of the Big Corporation
- The Gap-Old Navy Breakup
- Apples Acquisition of Intels Modem Business
- Mergers and Acquisitions: A New Perspective
- The CBS-Viacom Merger
- Why are Sprint Wireless and T-Mobile Funding their own Competition?
- Why are Corporations Hoarding Trillions in Cash?