MSG Team's other articles

11408 Key Components of Strategic Human Capital Plan

Employees – their knowledge, experience, skills, innovative ideas, concepts are all valued possessions within an organization. An organization must understand its employees well to expect the best from them. Human capital management refers to developing strategies to hire, manage, train, develop and retain top performing employees. Human Capital management includes the following: Recruiting the best […]

8792 What is Social Entrepreneurship? – Definition, its History and Concepts

Social entrepreneurship is all about recognizing the social problems and achieving a social change by employing entrepreneurial principles, processes and operations. It is all about making a research to completely define a particular social problem and then organizing, creating and managing a social venture to attain the desired change. The change may or may not […]

12175 The Return on Knowledge

Knowledge management has been a buzzword amongst modern day companies for a few years now. However, many companies are still skeptical about investing significant sums of money in a knowledge management system. This is because the return on knowledge management can be difficult to measure. When companies undertake other cost-cutting or business improvement activities, the […]

10354 Methods of Training Employees at Workplace

Trainings help employees enhance their capabilities and acquire new learnings, skills and knowledge. Trainings help employees come up with unique and innovative ideas, meet targets within the desired time frame and make them efficient resources for the organization. One needs to understand that lot of time, money and energy go in designing training programs for […]

9604 How Does ‘The Brand Called You’ Impact Your Employer Brand ?

Don’t miss on the best co-branding opportunity and let your personal and employer brands marry in harmony. True, your employer brand is one thing and your personal brand is the other. But as a top level executive, your personal brand can either be a promoter or detractor of your employer brand. What talent perceives about […]

Search with tags

  • No tags available.

Employees are Also Important Stakeholders

Contemporary organizations have to be accountable to a diverse range of stakeholders including customers, investors, regulators, and social activists as well as the wider civil society. However, what are missing in this list are the employees who are as important as the other stakeholders.

Indeed, while it is fashionable for organizations to take care of their external customers, often they forget that their employees matter as well. After all, it is the employees who make things possible for organizations with their hard work and contributions apart from their skills and expertise.

In recent months, there have been spates of corporate scandals relating to violation of ethics wherein companies such as the German Automobile major, Volkswagen, have admitted to “cheating” in terms of manufacturing cars that are designed to report false emissions levels.

This is a clear case of systemic failure since in this case, the company as a whole had “systemized” this aspect of manufacturing cars that are “geared to beat” the emissions norms.

However, what transpired in reality was that instead of admitting to systemic failures, the company simply fired some employees for being responsible for the scandal.

This Does Not Mean that Employees are Shielded

Having said that, it is not the contention here that organizations must shield errant and deviant employees as well as not take action against the top management and the CEOs since these people are the ones with the overall responsibility.

Indeed, if organizations do not take action against the top management, then the overall impression is that they are callous and unresponsive to the needs of the people. Therefore, our view in this aspect is that organizations must separate systemic failures from individual cases of deviance and take action accordingly.

Moving Away from the Scapegoat Culture

Further, organizations must also ensure that whenever there are systemic failures, then they must first start from the top instead of searching for “scapegoats” in the rank and file employees. In addition, our view is that whenever systemic failures happen because of bad policies, then the entire top management must be replaced as well as the Board of Directors being held to account.

Thus, what we are advocating is a more humane and humanitarian approach whenever there are corporate scandals wherein the need to “look within” and indulge in some “soul searching” would serve their cause rather than continuing with “business as usual”.

Some Examples from the Real World

For instance, after the worst disaster in the history of corporates which is the Bhopal Gas Leak incident, the senior management was shielded whereas the internal inquiries blamed individual employees for the disaster.

Even three decades after the incident, there is yet to be any progress in terms of admitting systemic and organization wide negligence that lead to the disaster. Apart from this, there are numerous examples of how systemic failures are “covered up” and instead the blame game starts wherein individual employees are punished.

This can be seen in the way the Big Banks in the United States and Europe were left off with fines and “slaps on the wrist” rather than being asked to “clean up” their entire pervasive culture of wrongdoing.

Indeed, the fact that these banks continue to indulge in “risky behavior” even now means that no lessons have been learnt from the Economic Crisis of 2008. In addition, there is also the case of the Enron scandal where though the top management and the leadership were handed jail terms, there was not attempt to go after the “enablers” such as the rating agencies, the financial regulators, and the broader institutional investors all of whom had a role to play in causing its collapse.

An On Balance Assessment of Accountability and Learning from Failures

On the other hand, organizations sometimes have the task of ensuring that errant and deviant behavior is punished. For instance, in recent years, there have been increasing instances of cyber crime targeting big corporations. The examples of Target and HSBC reveal that such hacking leads to losses for all stakeholders.

Therefore, it is indeed the fact that these organizations did the right thing by overhauling their digital networks and investing in better security software apart from establishing negligence and holding the concerned employees accountable.

Thus, as can be seen from the points made so far, organizations have to “balance” the needs of the various stakeholders including employees and at the same time, also have to ensure that after each incident and disaster, they engage in some serious probes into the systemic factors that are responsible for such incidents.

Indeed, the fact that the organizations which strive to do this are the ones that “emerge stronger” after each setback means that the longevity of such organizations is guaranteed. After all, the “show has to go on” and this means that just as we tend to rejuvenate ourselves after each setback, organizations too must pick up the pieces and rebuild themselves after each scandal and ensure that they learn the lessons from them.

Conclusion: What Separates the Truly Great Companies from the Rest?

In concluding the article, it would be worthwhile to note that any organization is prone to slipping every now and then as the rapid pace of business means that they tend to overreach, tend to over-commit, and tend to get carried away in the pursuit of profits.

However, what distinguishes the really great companies from the rest of the pack is their ability to learn from systemic failures, hold the right people responsible, and not continue with business as usual after disasters and setbacks.

Article Written by

MSG Team

An insightful writer passionate about sharing expertise, trends, and tips, dedicated to inspiring and informing readers through engaging and thoughtful content.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

Creativity and Entrepreneurship

MSG Team

Communication and Employee Development

MSG Team

Benefits of Employee Multitasking

MSG Team