The Case Against Labor Unions
April 3, 2025
It is a common belief amongst the general population that labor unions work in the interest of the laborers. In fact, they believe that the power that collective bargaining gives these workers is probably the only thing that prevents their exploitation at the hands of greedy corporations. They had all heard about the history of…
Why Wannabe Influencers and Creators Need a Reality Check on Social Media The rise of the Creator Economy in recent years has made some social media influencers very rich. Attracted by their successes, Millions of so-called Creators, who create everything from YouTube/TikTok videos, to Instagram reels, and LinkedIn articles, not to leave out Facebook and…
What is a Minimum Wage and Why is it so Contentious? Many of us would be familiar with the term Minimum Wage which is often argued as being necessary by labor union activists and worker federations. However, how many of us would know that this concept of a Minimum Wage is highly contentious not only…
These are the questions that Human Resources (HR) managers and the managers in organizations confront when they have to decide on hiring, firing, and rewarding employees.
Indeed, with technology becoming all pervasive and ubiquitous, employees are realizing that if they have to retain their jobs, they have to ramp up on their productivity. They are also realizing that competition from freelancers and contract workers who can do more in less time and also are cheap to the organization because the firms do not have to take care of other benefits except basic salary means that the full time employees in many organizations are feeling the heat.
Before we proceed further, let us look at how efficiency and productivity play out in the workplace. Some employees get work done in lesser time when compared to their peers.
For instance, if a particular employee takes 10 hours to do the task which other employees perform only in 15 to 20 hours, the former would be looked upon favorably by the managers because this employee can be made to work on more tasks in the time saved.
Further, if a particular employee increases the value added to the organization by taking initiatives such as designing tools for increased efficiency, he or she is adding more value than the others and hence, he or she would be rewarded accordingly.
Apart from this, if a particular employee takes fewer breaks as well as does not browse the web and check Facebook all the time, then the organization is likely to view these employees as more valuable assets when compared to the others. Indeed, the chances of these employees being fired are lesser or even nonexistent when economic conditions worsen.
As can be seen in the way many companies across the world are retaining their top performers and letting go of the ones who are less efficient and productive, it is clear that the workplace of the future would be dominated by the ultra productive and ultra efficient workforce.
No discussion on productivity and efficiency is complete without discussing the role of technology. Just as machines replaced workers in the mass manufacturing assembly lines and just as computers replaced even the most highly skilled employees in the past, now it is the combination of advanced computers and robots to replace the knowledge workers.
The fact that the knowledge workers or the workers who were employed in the services sector felt that by virtue of adding more value than the earlier workers whom they replaced, they were secure is now being questioned.
As the AI (Artificial Intelligence) algorithm based computers and robots are being introduced into firms, it is no longer the case that even the most valued adding employees can take their jobs for granted.
The point here is that technology follows the Moore’s law wherein the pace of change is such that the trends that are visible now would be replaced by newer trends within a time period of one to two years.
Therefore, what the professionals who are already working and those aspiring to enter the corporate world have to remember that in times when dizzying change is the norm, it pays to improve and enhance one’s skills on a continuous basis so that they are not left behind in the rat race with the changing trends.
Further, the fact that organizations are always looking to cut costs and boost profits means that one cannot expect charity from their managers and their organizations.
We have discussed how workers are threatened by more productive colleagues as well as threatened by technology. Another emerging threat to full time employees is from the growing army of freelancers and contractual employees.
As mentioned earlier, organizations do not have pay these workers anything more than the basic cost as healthcare, social security, and paid leave do not apply to them. This means that more and more, HR managers would be apt to shift to freelancers and contractual employees over full time workers. This also means that in the future, the existing workforce would be facing and confronting all these trends at the same time which would indeed be exhausting to contemplate.
If what has been discussed so far sounds alarmist and gloomy, we would suggest talking to older workers and those retired who in their times have had to confront computers and outsourcing replacing their jobs.
Further, we would also suggest considering the waves of change that have happened in the corporate world wherein the first casualties of any change were the slow moving who were simply replaced with the faster and more agile newer entrants.
The lesson for aspiring workers and the existing workforce is not to be tensed up or feel alarmed but look for ways and means to augment their productivity in addition to learning new skills or methods to add value by contributing in other areas than the regular work.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *