The Case Against Labor Unions
April 3, 2025
It is a common belief amongst the general population that labor unions work in the interest of the laborers. In fact, they believe that the power that collective bargaining gives these workers is probably the only thing that prevents their exploitation at the hands of greedy corporations. They had all heard about the history of…
Why Wannabe Influencers and Creators Need a Reality Check on Social Media The rise of the Creator Economy in recent years has made some social media influencers very rich. Attracted by their successes, Millions of so-called Creators, who create everything from YouTube/TikTok videos, to Instagram reels, and LinkedIn articles, not to leave out Facebook and…
What is a Minimum Wage and Why is it so Contentious? Many of us would be familiar with the term Minimum Wage which is often argued as being necessary by labor union activists and worker federations. However, how many of us would know that this concept of a Minimum Wage is highly contentious not only…
One of the more notable trends of the last decade or so has been the explosion in Gig Work or Part Time work wherein stringers and individuals work for Digital Platform Aggregators such as Amazon, Uber, and Urban Company, as well as for established Blue Chip firms in Manufacturing and Services.
Indeed, Gig Work has been the event of the last decade as firms in all sectors realized the value of Part Timers, not only to save costs, but also to optimize what is essentially piecemeal work that does not need full timers.
Moreover, with the nature of work itself changing and with the profusion of Digital Technologies, work no longer means something that is done in Physical and Fixed settings, but anywhere, everywhere, any time, and every time. For instance, task outsourcing firms such as Upwork can get done by Armies of Gig Workers located anywhere in the world whereas Cab Aggregators such as Uber do not need Full Time commitment from their Drivers.
All this has changed the nature of employment as we know it leading to newer forms of work and workers.
Having said that, while all this sounds exciting as Gig Work liberates the workers from having to remain loyal to a specific firm and instead, allows them to work for whomever they want, whenever they want, and wherever they want, the reality is that Gig Workers are more exploited and overworked than full timers without the attendant healthcare and social security benefits that the latter have.
The result has been an Epidemic of Stress and Burnout among Gig Workers that has been made worse due to the complete absence and lack of support from their employers.
Indeed, while Full Timers have their Annual Vacations, Sick Leaves, and Healthcare coverage as well as Social Security benefits, Gig Workers are at the mercy of external forces over which they have no control.
For instance, if someone who works for Uber or Task Rabbit falls ill or needs time off for personal and pressing work, he or she has to necessarily forego pay for that day in addition to having to pay out of pocket expenses for hospitalization and the like.
Worse, Gig Workers are also as good as their last assignment which means that they can be De-platformed for even minor infractions.
Therefore, it is our argument that Governments and Businesses worldwide wake up to the realities of Gig Work and take steps that would protect this vulnerable segment of society from disaster.
Already some states such as California in the United States are moving to legalize Gig Work and make Gig Workers eligible for some benefits, if not all that part timers receive.
Moreover, the United States anyway provides Unemployment Assistance to Gig Workers and moves are afoot by the Biden Administration to extend more such benefits to them.
The Indian Government too has made a start in this regard with the Latest Budget Proposals assuring state and private forms of assistance to Gig Workers.
The point here is that Governments must also nudge the Private Sector to do more for their Part Timers not only as a humanitarian imperative, but also from a purely cost benefit point of view as they ought not to kill the Golden Goose that Lays the Eggs.
In other words, considering the humungous cost savings to such firms from Gig Workers, it is only natural that they get something in return for their services.
With Gig Work projected to grow exponentially, benefits too must reach them.
Another argument why Gig Workers need more assistance, recognition, and rewards is that at the moment, the distinction and the categorization of such work is hazy and confusing that is leading to unintended consequences for both the workers and their employers.
The question of responsibility and accountability looms large as far as how mishaps and accidents in the line of duty are treated. Suppose an Uber driver is involved in an accident either through negligence or due to factors beyond his or her control.
The question of who pays the compensation to the victims as well as the damages is still unclear as are wider questions regarding whether Uber would provide legal and administrative assistance to their drivers by way of any action that the authorities may take against them.
In addition, without secure employment, it is natural for Gig Workers to work in multiple platforms that again bring to the fore issues related to payment of benefits.
The only way out of this would be for the Governments to create a Fund, with contributions from the Platform Economy and the Physical Firms for Gig Workers that can be used to provide succour and assistance in the situations described above.
Last, the world is in the throes of what experts have described as the Fourth Industrial Revolution that is beginning to redraw our notions of work, leisure, employment, and broader ways of living.
It is only natural that we take steps to redefine these times for the New Realities. In the same manner in which the First Industrial Revolution led to the creation and passage of institutions and laws that were aimed at the then work and employment conditions, the emerging and changing rules of the game need a new approach to the Post Pandemic New Normal in the world.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *