Mortgage Lending: Borrower Approach vs Collateral Approach
The subprime mortgage crisis was basically a clash of ideologies. These ideologies were related to the centuries old belief regarding how money should be lent out versus the new age beliefs regarding how money should be lent out. The old age belief was that money is being lent out to the borrower and that collateral […]
China’s Modern Day Ghost Cities
The GDP system has found several criticisms. However, none of the criticisms have been as apparent as an unusual phenomenon called “ghost cities” and “ghost towns” which have cropped up all across China. The sheer wastage and diversion of resources to non productive purposes to meet the government’s targets for GDP growth is apparent in […]
The Discouraged Worker Flaw
In this article, we will explain the first and probably the largest flaw in the calculation of unemployment rate i.e. the discouraged worker flaw. This issue has been widely debated in the media and amongst the experts for years. However, little has been done to make the average person aware of it. Fine Print in […]
Cyclical Unemployment – Definition, Causes and Cure
In the previous two articles, we studied about frictional and structural unemployment. They can be considered to be the mild and moderate form of unemployment respectively that can be suffered by an economy. They are not usually the ones being referred to when common people talk about unemployment. The most dreaded form of unemployment is […]
The Impact of Real Estate Bankruptcies
The past five years have been very difficult for the Indian real estate sector. The entire sector was coming from a very high point. The economy was booming, and sales would increase even as the prices went up year after year. However, after 2013, the Indian real estate market stagnated. As prices did not increase, […]
The rise of firms like Uber, Lyft, TaskRabbit, and Airbnb have startled many economists. The number of people working for these firms has risen drastically. This is the reason that many economists have gone overboard. Many of them claim that the gig economy is the way workforce will be employed in the future. They are of the opinion that the gig economy will replace the existing employment contracts that are currently used all over the world.
It may be tempting to think that the gig economy will grow so big that it will consume the actual economy. However, the numbers suggest otherwise. For instance, even after all these unicorns, the gig economy currently employs close to 1% of the total workforce in America. That is still a minuscule number given the fact that over 85% of Americans are still employed with traditional contracts.
In this article, we will argue that the gig economy will continue to remain a side gig and will not take over the future.
During the 20th century, almost everyone in America and the entire world was self-employed. The 9 to 5 job is a pretty recent invention. However, it has rapidly taken over most of the workforce in America. Proponents of the gig economy believe that gigs are just an efficient way to take us back into the past. If the workforce all over the world was self-employed for most historical periods, why should the future be any different?
Workforce all over the world has evolved from subcontracting to permanent employment. This is because of the many advantages that working for a firm offers. From an individual standpoint, the wages are fixed, and the benefits are good. Therefore, workers do not have to suffer the uncertainty that self-employment entails. From the firm’s point of view, if they employ sub-contractors for everything, they might perform well as individuals. However, subcontractors will be competitors and therefore will not have any incentive to co-operate with other subcontractors. This will create a lot of friction within the firm itself. This friction will impede decision making and day to day operations. Therefore, sub-contracting will turn out to be much more expensive as compared to direct employment.
However, if the gig economy is so inconvenient and uneconomical, then why are so many people working in it!
The answer to the above question lies in the fact that Uber and Airbnb are the most successful gig economy companies. It is no surprise that these companies deal in real estate and transportation. Most people tend to buy a bigger home and more expensive car than they can afford. Also, when people are laid off, home and car is the only capital that they have. This is the reason why they try to use that capital to make a living. It would, therefore, be appropriate to say that only because housing and transportation require no special skill or capital that they have become the most popular sectors in the gig economy.
Studies conducted into the nature of the gig economy have made another interesting revelation. Most people that work in the gig economy view it as temporary work. More than 50% of the workers in the gig economy only work less than three months in the year! Therefore the gig economy does not comprise of jobs which employees want to take on for the long term. These are jobs which people take when they want immediate cash. For instance, these jobs are taken by people who are currently between jobs or want to work part-time since they are still in college. Hence, the gig economy will always only be a small subsection of the total economy.
Robotic process automation is an important part of the future of jobs. In the future, there will be very few menial jobs which will be performed by humans. The majority of the menial jobs will be automated. This can be seen from the rise of robots which are being used in warehouses as well as self-driving cars.
Since there will be so much automation, there will be an increased requirement for people who work in technology. Technological jobs will require people to perform complex tasks which require a lot of training and education. It wouldn’t be possible to execute such tasks via the gig economy. This is because the gig economy typically does not include tasks where workers are expected to take a lot of responsibility.
The bottom line is that the uberization of tasks can only happen to a certain extent and for certain jobs. It is unlikely that the entire economy will start following the principles of the gig economy. The reality is that the gig economy is not really beneficial to the worker or the employer. Both parties have to live with uncertainty. This reduces the service level, which negates any price advantage, which this model may have to offer.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
The Creator Economy Is a Passport to Riches for a Few, a Pipe Dream for the Rest
February 12, 2025
Why Gig Work is Here to Stay and How We Need New Laws and Institutions for Them
February 12, 2025
