Marxian Traditions and their Approach to Public Administration
Karl Marx has often been cited as the most powerful personality in the history of human civilization. He was a philosopher while being an economist, a socialist who was also a journalist and a historian who proposed the materialist conception of history. His views regarding his areas of work and interests are collectively termed as Marxian.
Karl Marx was a rebel in many ways which also contributed to his abilities to look and understand beyond the obvious. He firmly believed that the world cannot be changed just by generating ideas; changes can be brought in, only by real, physical activity.
Even as a student Marx was deeply influenced by the work of German philosopher G.W.F.Hegel. It was Hegel who inspired Marx to switch from legal studies to philosophy; a fact Marx admitted in a letter to his father, justifying his decision.
What is interesting is that, Hegel and his inspiration did not prevent Marx from comprehending the lacunae between the rational and the real in the philosophies of Hegel. One of his important works was his Critique of Hegels Philosophy of the Right. It is advisable to the reader to do a little background study about the philosophy and works of G.W.F. Hegel, to understand the above discussion in a better light.
It would only make sense to point out to the readers at this stage is that Marx wrote very little about bureaucracy as such, and mostly after 1843. However whatever little he wrote gives a clear understanding of his stand regarding the need and relevance of bureaucracy in a modern State. Marx believed that understanding the functionalism and structuralism of bureaucracy was critical because it is the political expression of the division of labor.
In his The Eighteenth Brumaire, Marx calls France as the abode to bureaucracy as opposed to Germany which in his opinion, up until then was the supreme example of oppressive bureaucratic conditions in the states. He suggests that bureaucracy create conditions which subjects people to gross manipulations.
Another important deviation from the Hegel influence can be viewed in the manner Marx and Hegel understood bureaucracy. According to Hegel public administration was a bridge between the State and civil societies. The state through bureaucracy joined various particular interest to arrive at one general interest.
On the other hand Marx viewed that the State did not represent the general interest but the interests of the ruling or the dominant class. And obvious enough, this class was a part of the civil society. He went on to say that in a capitalist economy, the bureaucracy is aligned with the dominant class and it masquerades the interests of this dominant class as the general interest which is subsequently forced on the society.
While reading Marx on bureaucracy one can visualize it as an oppressive, mysterious system beyond the understanding or control of common people. It has certain symbols and secret ways of working and staunch traditions which makes it inherently incompetent in so many ways. Lenin was a follower of Marxian approach on bureaucracy and had ruled out any scope of it when the capitalism would be thrown out of Russian. But, after 1917, when he came into power, he could not help but rely on bureaucracy to help him run the State.
Marx was never oblivious to the growing popularity of bureaucracy and the need of public administration as an aspect of Government functioning, around the world. Nevertheless, this promulgation of bureaucracy did not prevent him to see the dangerous loopholes it carried.
|❮❮ Previous||Next ❯❯|
- Structural Functional Approach to Public Administration
- Public Policy Approach to Public Administration
- Political Economy Approach to Public Administration
- Political Science & Public Administration
- Role of Public Administration in the Modern State
Authorship/Referencing - About the Author(s)
The article is Written By Prachi Juneja and Reviewed By Management Study Guide Content Team. MSG Content Team comprises experienced Faculty Member, Professionals and Subject Matter Experts. We are a ISO 2001:2015 Certified Education Provider. To Know more, click on About Us. The use of this material is free for learning and education purpose. Please reference authorship of content used, including link(s) to ManagementStudyGuide.com and the content page url.
- Public Administration - Introduction
- Nature & Scope of Public Administration
- Public Administration: An Art or a Science
- Public and Private Administration
- Woodrow Wilsons Vision on PA
- New Public Management
- Approaches to Public Administration
- Historical and Legal Approach in PA
- Institutional Approach to PA
- Behavioral Systems Approach to PA
- Closed and Open Models of PA
- Structural Functional Approach to PA
- Public Policy Approach to PA
- Political Economy Approach to PA
- Marxian Approach to PA
- Political Science & Public Administration
- Role of PA in the Modern State
- Democratic and Socialist Goals
- Challenges in a Developed Society
- Challenges in a Developing Society
- Classical Theory of Public Administration
- Human Relations Theory
- Bureaucratic Theory
- Post Weberian Models
- Line Staff and Auxiliary Agencies
- Departments as Units of Organizations
- Bureau System Vs Board System
- What are Public Enterprises ?
- Administrative Decision Making
- Personnel Administration
- Budget in Public Administration
- Different Types of Budgets
- Budgetary Process in Different Countries
- Importance of Audit
- Law, Regulations and Reforms
- What is Development Administration ?
- Comparative Public Administration
- The Future of Public Administration