Arguments against Tax Competition
February 12, 2025
Every firm has a predefined goal or an objective. Therefore the most important goal of a financial manager is to increase the owner’s economic welfare. Here economics welfare may refer to maximization of profit or maximization of shareholders wealth. Therefore Shareholders wealth maximization (SWM) plays a very crucial role as far as financial goals of […]
Human beings are social animals. For centuries, our brains have been wired to conform to the actions of the larger group. This is because, in the old times, a person’s probability of survival would be negatively impacted if they were not in a group. This herding mentality may have helped our forefathers survive in the […]
Throughout finance, one rule always holds true. The general belief is that the value of any asset or security is exactly equal to the discounted present value of all the cash flows that can be derived from it in future periods. Using this principle, one can easily value securities like debt. This is because they […]
Most investors across the world are aware of the fact that yield curves are generally upward sloping. This is because, under normal circumstances, yields for bonds with longer maturities tend to be higher. However, it is possible for the opposite scenario to play out. This means that it is possible for bonds with lower maturities […]
What are Bills of Exchange? A bill of exchange is a promissory note that is usually issued by the buyer to the seller of goods in return for the goods. The seller would like to sell their goods for cash. However, in certain cases, the buyer may not have cash immediately at the moment. However, […]
Before the advent of globalization, every country in the world was working in a vacuum when it came to taxes. This is because the companies which operate in these countries did not have any choice when it came to tax rates.
Their only choices were to accept the tax rates or to stop production. If they did not like the tax policy of the country, they could undertake political protests.
However, there was nothing else they could do to increase their own financial gain. In economic terms, it can be said that the government is the monopoly supplier.
Hence, like all monopoly suppliers, the government has no incentive to reduce its costs, and hence inefficiency becomes the norm.
All this changed with globalization. After globalization, countries were free to incorporate and operate in different parts of the world. If they did not like the tax policy of a country, they could simply move to another country. This policy of free movement of capital gave rise to tax competition.
Tax competition means that countries have to compete with each other in order to get companies to incorporate and operate within their boundaries. Since countries now had to attract companies, a wave of rationalizations and tax cuts followed. There are several benefits to tax competition. Some of them have been explained in this article.
As such, they would keep increasing budgets by incurring non-productive expenses for personal political gains. Without tax competition, politicians are free to channel the resources of the country in the backward direction i.e., from the industrious to the idle.
Tax completion encourages the government to be lean. Only if a government can reduce its wasteful expenditure can it lower the tax rate, and only after the tax rate is lowered can more companies be attracted.
Then, politicians would selectively give tax breaks to certain companies and distort capital allocation in the economy. This chain has been broken by globalization. This is because firstly, entrepreneurs nowadays are not restricted to domestic capital.
If they provide an efficient product or service, they can obtain money from foreign investors as well. The capital pool is much larger. Also, if the government’s tax policy is not efficient, then the company can simply migrate to a different country. Hence, government interference in the allocation of capital is minimized.
They are supposed to provide services such as electricity and transport at low rates. With the advent of tax competition, companies now look at countries where they can get the best value for money.
Hence, sometimes companies may choose to go for a country with a higher tax rate if that means getting access to better public services such as an educated workforce that has access to a good healthcare system.
However, it can be brought to a minimum. The lower the taxes in an economy, the more productively the resources are used.
Hence, if the tax is reduced, it leads to more money in the hands of the workers. This higher disposable income can then lead to increased consumption. This increases the overall economic activity in a nation, which leads to the collection of more taxes.
Hence, it lowered its tax rates. Now, there are a lot of companies which have headquartered in Ireland. Therefore, low tax rates have been the main reason why companies have migrated to Ireland, which has led to economic development in that region.
The good thing about tax competition is that once a few governments adopt this model, the others do not have a choice. This is what has happened in the modern world.
After most of the western governments adopted tax competition, other developing countries had to follow suit. Also, countries cannot stop tax competition unilaterally.
They have to get other governments to agree. For instance, European governments have been trying to harmonize their tax rates to eliminate tax advantages but have not been able to do so.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *