Comparing Different Financial Systems
February 12, 2025
Whenever a person from the baby boomer generation hears the term pension plan, they refer to defined benefit pension plans. Defined benefit pension plans were the predominant type of pension plan just a few decades ago. In the 1980s, defined benefit plans accounted for over 80% of all types of pension plans which were offered […]
Accounting for pension funds is considered to be much more complex than standard accounting. This is because a lot of the payments being made in the pension funds are to be done in the distant future. Hence, as an accountant, provisions have to be made to account for these expenses as well as incomes that […]
The ultimate aim of all business is to generate profit. That is what the investors invest for, management plans for and employees execute for. Profitability Needs Context Two companies may be generating the exact same amount of rupee profits, however that does not mean that they are equally profitable. This is because profit is an […]
We have already seen the various ways in which technology has shaped the commercial banking domain. However, the commercial banking domain is so vast that it is being concurrently affected by many big changes. The increasing use of artificial intelligence for commercial lending is another important trend that is impacting the commercial bank lending industry. […]
In the previous article, we have already seen that it is common for sporting franchises to raise significant amounts of debt funding. We also know that there are certain special characteristics of sports franchises that need to be taken into account before giving out loans to them. One more such important characteristic of debt funding […]
Stress testing is a type of simulation model which is used to manage risks in banks and other financial institutions. As a part of stress testing, various mathematical and analytical techniques are deployed to understand how an organization would react to adverse outcomes in the external environment.
Stress testing is useful to understand how a portfolio would behave if several unforeseen circumstances took place simultaneously. These simulations are not performed by normal risk management models since they are considered to be outliers. However, the entire purpose of stress testing is to verify whether the financial system is equipped to deal with exceptional situations if the need arises.
Stress testing is conducted by creating scenarios that mimic the external world. In order to be able to do so, the financial analyst needs to have a clear understanding of the factors which impact the value of underlying assets.
A combination of these factors is then called a scenario. Scenarios can be drawn up in one of two ways.
Firstly, scenarios can be created based on hypothetical data. This means that it is assumed that extreme financial events that happened in the past are about to reoccur. However, what happened in the past, many not necessarily repeat in the future. Hence, financial analysts have to get creative and think about the various scenarios which could possibly happen in the future.
After these scenarios are identified, the performance of an institution or even the entire system needs to be simulated. This means that a financial model must be prepared, which can predict how the system will react if a particular scenario actually takes place. This would involve identifying the assets which would face stress and the corresponding fall in their value. Simultaneously, the value of other assets may increase. This should also be considered in the stress test.
The possible courses of action which can be taken should also be considered. The financial impact of the decisions taken in each case should be noted down. The results can then be shared in a training session with the decision-makers. This would enable them to manage an adverse situation better as and when it occurs.
The aggregate stress testing of the financial system is quite different from the testing of an individual firm.
Aggregate tests are done in order to understand the breaking point wherein the entire financial system will collapse.
On the other hand, individual stress tests are done to understand how a particular company can reduce its exposure to the amount of risk in the economy.
The decisions taken at the end of both types of stress tests are very different. Regulators make decisions about changing the rules and regulations in the marketplace in order to make it safer and more effective. On the other hand, individual companies take decisions which help them decide the appropriate level of leverage which they should maintain
When the portfolio of the entire system is to be considered, firstly, the firms which need to be added in the analysis need to be defined. Banks and major financial institutions are always considered to be a part of the system. The problem is about which smaller firms need to be included in the analysis.
The degree of integration with other financial systems also makes it difficult to conduct stress testing.
If the market has a lot of foreign investors from a different country, then their markets will also be adversely impacted by the negative events happening in a different country. On the other hand, if these external institutions guarantee the financial well being of their local subordinates, then even the impact of local conditions is reduced significantly.
Foreign banks and companies can potentially transmit as well as absorb shocks based on their financial standing. This impact is difficult to gauge while conducting a stress test.
The methodology of stress testing also needs to be decided beforehand. The results of the stress test can be very different if the stressor factors are applied to the entire system vis-a-vis if they are applied to individual firms in the system.
The bottom line is that stress testing is a very important method for gauging the stability of the financial system. However, it is quite complex, which makes it difficult to execute in real life.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *