Scarcity vs. Abundant Mindsets in Leaders
Scarcity and Abundance
We often hear the terms scarcity and abundance mindsets of employees and employers in addition to leaders. These terms are used to refer to the mindset of the individuals who think in constrained or scarcity mindsets as opposed to those who think in terms of abundance.
Indeed, even in our daily lives, we make choices between adopting a mindset that thinks in terms of scarce resources and constrained choices as opposed to those who visualize abundance as far as their attitudes are concerned.
These terms have also become more relevant in contemporary times when there are resource shortages which mean that having a scarcity mindset is not always bad. Having said that, considering that technology and innovation have the potential to usher in abundance, it is worth noting that having an abundant mindset is preferable in many situations where leaders have to have the vision to think in terms of growth, prosperity, and affluence for all.
Differences between Scarcity and Abundance Mindsets
Next, let us examine the differences between leaders who have a scarcity mindset as opposed to those who have an abundant mindset.
Scarcity Mindset leaders and Abundance mindsets differ in the following ways
- Whereas the former are resource constrained meaning they think in terms of shortages, savings, keeping resources to themselves and a mentality which promotes individual selfishness over collective good, leaders with an abundant mindset think in terms of collective solutions, collaboration, encouraging creativity, and fostering a culture of high performance.
- Perhaps the most important difference is that scarcity mindset leaders think in terms of zero-sum game situations where an individual or an organization can succeed only if they behave in I win/ You Lose thinking. While this is not necessarily bad considering that the very nature of competition is such that somebody has to lose if one has to win, when it comes to the internal processes of the organization, leaders have to think in terms of abundance wherein they believe that I Win/You Win and We All Win meaning that they have to encourage their employees not to compete with each other but collaborate and coordinate with each other.
- Further, it is often the case that leaders with scarcity mindsets are prone to be fearful, play politics, and are limited in their vision. On the other hand, leaders with abundance mindsets are visionary, are role models for their employees, and ensure that their employees thrive and prosper leading to organizational success.
- At the same time, in emerging markets such as India and China, it is often difficult for leaders to constantly think in terms of abundance because of the limitations of the system. Indeed, even in the West, there are many organizational experts who believe that while it sounds idealistic to say that leaders must have an abundance mindset, the realities of the marketplace are such that scarcity often delivers the best results.
- Having said that, let us compare two legends of technology, Bill Gates of Microsoft, and the Late Steve Jobs of Apple. While both were indeed visionary and successful and at the same time had both scarcity and abundance mindsets, it is the degree or the extent to which one trait dominated in the sense that while Steve Jobs was willing to go with open source software, Bill Gates resisted the concept and continues to do so even now. It is another matter that Gates has also contributed to society through his foundation which has seen him donning the role of a social messiah.
Situational Leadership vs. Management
The point we are trying to make here is that both scarcity and abundance mindsets are present in all leaders and considering that management is situational and leadership is visionary, the outcomes for organizations depends to the extent in which the scarcity managerial model combines with the visionary abundance leadership model in determining the route taken by the organization as well as the culture in such organizations.
Leaders and Social Obligations and the Value they create for Society
Moreover, it needs to be remembered that organizations and business leaders have a social and moral responsibility towards society.
Therefore, when evaluating leaders with either or both of the mindsets, one must take into account how much value they have created for society. In this context, it is worth noting that while the megabanks in the West make more profits and money than many other organizations, leaders of other companies are more respected because their abundance mindsets ensure that they give back to society in the same manner in which society has contributed to their success.
Conclusion: Listen to your Inner Voice for Guidance
Therefore, in the ultimate analysis, it is the case that what works in one situation might not work in other situations and hence, whichever mindset you are going to adopt would depend on what your inner voice says about competition, collaboration, and coordination as well as moral and social obligations to your peers, families, friends, and colleagues and more importantly, to the wider society to which you belong.
|❮❮ Previous||Next ❯❯|
Authorship/Referencing - About the Author(s)
The article is Written By Prachi Juneja and Reviewed By Management Study Guide Content Team. MSG Content Team comprises experienced Faculty Member, Professionals and Subject Matter Experts. We are a ISO 2001:2015 Certified Education Provider. To Know more, click on About Us. The use of this material is free for learning and education purpose. Please reference authorship of content used, including link(s) to ManagementStudyGuide.com and the content page url.
- Leadership - Introduction
- Importance of Leadership
- Role of a Leader
- Qualities of a Leader
- Leadership and Management
- Leader versus Manager
- Authority vs Leadership
- Leadership and Motivation
- Emotional Intelligence for Leaders
- Organizational Leadership
- Leadership Ethics
- Leadership Strategy
- Leadership Styles
- Personal Leadership Brand
- Level 5 Leadership
- Situational Leadership
- Situational Leadership and Motivation
- Leadership & Subordinate Development
- Leadership Development - Introduction
- Intrinsic vs Extrinsic Motivation
- Inside Leaders vs. Outside Leaders
- Transformational Leadership
- Leadership for the 21st Century
- The Transleader
- Three Traits of Effective Leadership
- Importance of Compassion in Leadership
- An Important Advice to Future Leaders
- Avoiding Focus on Quarterly Earnings
- Reinventing Management for 21st Century
- Ambidextrous Leadership
- Invest in Oneself
- Social Media Skills for Leaders
- Social Stratification and Hierarchy
- The Ethical Imperative
- Leadership in the Face of Adversity
- Emotional and Spiritual Intelligence
- Leadership Theories
- Blake and Moutons Managerial Grid
- Houses Path Goal Theory
- Great Man Theory
- Trait Theory
- LMX Theory
- Transformational Leadership
- Transactional Leadership
- Continuum of Leadership Behaviour
- Likerts Management System
- Hersey Blanchard Model
- Fiedlers Contingency Model
- Leadership and Trust
- How to be a Good Leader ?
- Effective Leadership Skills
- Leadership Vision
- Different Types of Power
- Women and Leadership
- What are the Challenges in Leadership ?
- Tips to Overcome Challenges in Leadership
- Role of Communication in Overcoming Leadership Challenges
- Role of Management/Organization in Overcoming Leadership Challenges
- Tips to Strengthen Bond Among Employees
- Vision of Leaders has to be Actualized by Middle Management for Organizational Success
- Leadership in the Time of Epic Changes and Struggles Over Ethics and Values
- Great Leadership is about Initiating, Sustaining, and Carrying through Ones Vision
- Cultural Dimensions of Leadership
- Scarcity vs. Abundant Mindsets in Leaders
- Different Folks, Different Strokes! The Many Leadership Styles in the Real World
- Persuasion and the Art of Changing Minds are Essential for Contemporary Leaders
- Managing in Chaos: A Necessary Skill for Managers and Leaders
- Leadership in the Contemporary World
- Need to Develop Network Thinking and Seventh Sense for Success in the 21st Century
- Why Do Some Business Leaders Attain Greatness Whereas Others Fail?
- Hands on Approach to Leadership: The Need for Leaders to be Good Administrators
- How Great Leaders Transform Organizations, Nations, Societies, and the World
- Why Business and Political Leaders Must be Institution Builders to Ensure Longevity
- Qualities of an Inspirational Leader and their Benefits
- Foundation Pillars of Successful Leaders
- Self Assessment for Leadership: Assessing the Strengths and Vulnerabilities for Improving Leadership Effectiveness
- Self Motivation for Leaders
- Techniques for Developing Self-Motivation
- Leadership Development Plan
- Writing a Leadership Development Plan
- When Hope Meets Reality: The Challenges for Leaders to Sustain the Momentum
- The Challenge for Contemporary Leaders is to Restore Trust and Faith in Institutions
- The Ever Shortening Business Cycles and What They Mean for Business Leaders
- Leadership Case Study: Steve Jobs - The Man Who Ushered in the Smartphone Revolution
- Why Leaders Must be in Control over the Direction and Pace of Organizational Change
- The 4Cs of Leadership Styles for Leadership in the Digital Age
- Lessons for Business Leaders from the Downfall of Charles Ghosn of Renault - Nissan
- Truly Great Leadership is All about Walking the Talk in All Aspects of Being Leaders
- Examining the Crisis of the Leader Follower Relationship in the Present Times
- How Great Leaders use a Mix of Micromanagement and Hands off Approaches
- Leadership during Crises is what Distinguishes Great Leaders from Manager Leaders
- What the Dalai Lama can teach Corporate Honchos about Leadership and Management
- Why we Need more Emotionally Intelligent Leaders and Managers in Chaotic Times
- Why the Digital Age Calls for a New Approach to Leadership and Team Management
- Business Leadership in the Age of Nationalism and Populism and the Rocky Road Ahead
- Leadership in a Collapsing World When Faced with Insurmountable Problems
- The Importance of Thought Leaders and Influencers in the Age of Social Media
- Leadership by Optics Management: Taking the Howdy Modi Event as a Case Study
- What Should Leaders do in Low Growth and Recessionary Times
- What Ails India Inc. and is it a Crisis of Leadership or a Structural Issue to be Addressed?
- The Tyranny of the Quarterly Results: Why Business Leaders must Avoid Short-Termism
- The Perils of Leaders and Their Personality Cults in Times of Authoritarian Rulers
- Leadership in the Digital Age and Why Contemporary Leaders Must Master These Skills
- Misdemeanours by Senior Leaders Must Be Handled Firmly and the Right Message Sent
- When Hope Meets Reality: Why Visionary Leaders Have to Balance Dreams with Realities
- Power as a Managerial Tool
- Why We Need More Self Aware and Less Self Centred Leaders, Who Can Self Evaluate