MSG Team's other articles

11026 Risk and Control Self-Assessment (RCSA): What is it, What are the Benefits, and How is it Done?

Risk and control self-assessment (RCSA) is an internal procedure used to identify, assess, and mitigate operational risks within a company.1 In this article, we will discuss the purpose and benefits of this process, before exploring the key stages involved in conducting a thorough RCSA. What is the Purpose of an RCSA? Regular engagement in RCSAs […]

10099 Key Factors in Effective Change Management

Successful organizations evolve at lightning speed for remaining competitive and gaining a winning edge across the industry. This can be fulfilled by building the adaptive mechanisms and proactively dealing with the environmental pressures and responding to the changing needs of the present times. By adopting a holistic approach, visionary leadership as well as support from […]

13045 Cyber Risk in Reinsurance

The global business environment has turned increasingly digital in the pasts few years. It is very common for businesses across the world to conduct most of their business online. This includes transacting with customers, employees, suppliers, and even the government. It is for this reason that the role of computers has drastically increased within the […]

11704 Types of Teams – Permanent Teams, Temporary Teams, Task Force, Virtual Teams etc

When individuals with a common interest, goal, attitude, need and perception come together, a team is formed. Individuals need to come and work together to form a team for the accomplishment of complicated tasks. In a team, all team members contribute equally and strive hard to achieve the team’s objective which should be predefined. In […]

9820 Importance of Character in Personality Development

Let us first understand what does character mean? Character refers to the sum of an individual’s qualities and characteristics which differentiate him/her from others. An individual’s character is actually an amalgamation of his/her qualities which makes him unique and helps him stand apart from the rest. Character plays an essential role in Personality Development Remember […]

Search with tags

  • No tags available.

The world has been in economic turmoil for the past century. One crisis after other has struck in different parts of the world. This is happening simultaneously with growing emphasis on economic education.

Universities and schools all over the world are devoting more resources and manpower to economics than they have ever done before. Yet the results are dismal to say the least. It seems like economic studies are actually detrimental. First no one seems to know what the correct course of action is and second there are many contradictory points of view that add to the confusion!

Many argue that this is because economics is inherently unstable since it has been built on a set of false assumptions. In this article, we will have a closer look at some of the commonly used assumptions in economic theory and see why they could possibly lead to wrong conclusions.

Rational Behavior Assumption

The first page of any economic textbook assumes that man is a social animal and has a rational behavior. It sounds like a reasonable assumption to make but it is not. This is because it describes how things are supposed to be in the world rather than how they actually are.

People are supposed to make rational decisions but they never do. How else can one explain the massive purchases of products like alcohol and cigarettes, products that only kill and provide no benefit whatsoever? Which rational person will pay money to be closer to death and sickness? Also, why would someone purchase Calvin Klein handbags for thousands of dollars when they can are made in some sweatshop for a few dollars!

The bottom line is that human beings make purchases based on emotions. This is why most advertisements target the emotions of their viewers. Yet, economics simply ignores this fact and constructs theory believing that rational assumptions are imperative.

Transaction Cost Assumption

A lot of economic theory is based on the assumption that there are no transaction costs involved. However, in the real world transaction costs do exist for every transaction. There are brokerages involved and also taxation takes a share of the pie.

This distorts the transaction to a great extent. This is because in theory one could go on transacting indefinitely without incurring any charges. However, in reality when one undertakes a transaction, charges are levied on them. This is what prevents them from entering in such transaction and therefore supply is significantly reduced from what theory would suggest. This also has an impact on the price.

Perfect Knowledge Assumption

Economic theory assumes perfect knowledge. This is another irrational assumption. In the real world, consumers face an infinite number of choices. They neither have the information required to make the decisions nor the capability to acquire it! Even if they did somehow acquire the information, it will be impossible to process it and reach a sound conclusion.

Economic theory should be based on the fact that humans make imperfect decisions with their limited knowledge instead of simply assuming perfect information! If the past few decades are any proof, companies with superior information systems win over their competition. Hence assuming similar information systems makes the whole field of information technology redundant.

Homogeneity Assumption

Economic theory assumes homogeneity. This means that when they mention a term “buyer” for instance, they believe that all buyers are the same and that one can replace the other. In reality that is not the case. Neither people nor goods are exactly homogeneous. Instead, there is inherent variation present in the world. Making assumptions to the contrary simply leads to the creation of a theory that proves to be false in the real world.

Self Corrective Assumption

Economic theory also believes that market mechanisms are perfect. The idea is that so many people are involved that if some fault did exist, the market would correct itself. However, markets do tend to get considerably off balance in the short term. Consider the case of any economic bubble and you will see that markets have been off fundamentals for prolonged periods of time, sometimes for years! Hence, if people believe that markets are always perfect and invest accordingly they are likely to lose money. Similarly if economic theory is built on this argument it may lead to disastrous conclusions.

Agency Assumptions

Economic theory assumes that agents behave in line with the interests of the principal. Theories do assume an agency problem but they believe that it can be sorted out. However, that is rarely the case. Consider the case of the largest and most wasteful expenditures in the world and you will find that the money is spent by the government.

Governments spend people’s money. However, the objective is to get the best economic return for the politicians themselves. This is a big conflict of interest and is rarely modeled in economic modeling. Yet when we see any major crisis, we always see that corruption is the main cause!

Economic theory is therefore built on shaky grounds. For these theories to be any good, we would need a radical revamp of economic as a science right from the grassroots levels. For now, investors should reduce the reliance on these theories and must be aware of the pitfalls of reaching conclusions based on them.

Article Written by

MSG Team

An insightful writer passionate about sharing expertise, trends, and tips, dedicated to inspiring and informing readers through engaging and thoughtful content.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

Concept of Property in Political Science

MSG Team

Are We Really Capitalists ?

MSG Team